No one mentioned the conditions their fishing their jigs in nor what type of jigs.
I fish a lot of football heads as my lakes are rocky (with clear water). For football heads (depending on the size of the jig and skirt), NetBait Paca Chunks, Berkley Chigger Craws (both types), Rage Tail chunks, RI Sweet Beavers, Double-tail grubs. I don't fish many swim jigs, but when I do I like a trailer with some sort of action in the tail like a swim senko, curly tail grub, the longer football head trailers with all the appendages detached from each other. Flipping jigs I tend to use the smaller football head trailers with the most action on the fall.
Color-wise I tend to stay away from anything that doesn't look like local forage, so lots of natural colors from red to brown to green to black with different highlights or sparkle.