Thank you for validating the point I was trying to make. I respect the fact that you--as one with a vested interest--are not trying to make silly claims like "my lure catches more fish than your lure."
I can readily accept verifiable differences in lures such as quality of components, hook sharpness, durability, tuning required, made in USA, or whatever.
Whether it's a buzzbait, crankbait, hunk of plastic, jig or others, or the actual lure color, we're venturing into the unknown when we say one outfishes the other.
Too often we tend to extrapolate and state as facts our preferences, biases and confidence factors. I have an incredible amount of confidence in Jitterbugs and that's the only topwater I want to use when conditions will allow use of treble hooks. But I never have and never will claim that it's better than some other topwater or that someone else will do better by switching to them.
Marty - it seems that you are pretty adamant about what you are saying. By all means you're right. Heck I could fish a body of water with an old Luhr Jensen Kwickfish that has lost its paint and crappy old hooks on it and do much better than using the expensive new shallow running crankbaits. However, some people like certain things and will continue to use them. The fact is sometimes the fish will only be fooled by certain things and presentations, that's the fun here. People are here to talk about what is good for them, maybe you try it maybe you don't, but there's always the chess game of choosing how to use something properly in the right conditions. I say chess, but it's more of a crapshoot.