I must admit that i am the same way, i dont use my old baits unless i have backups. I would hate to catch a boat load on them and not have another for my partner or incase you do the dreaded ( Loose one ).
Pre- rapala wiggle warts, Bill Dance Fat Frees, Risto Raps, Fat Raps.
These are the main ones, its sad but i catch more fish on the old wiggle warts than the new ones.
They are pricey but the way i look at it, its just like buying a
Lucky Craft.