I have pulled a 3lb. Largie out of the water three times on the hook set and finally landed him on the fourth. All together he ate the frog 7 times. Same fish, I watched him for most of it. No, it was not a spawner. This is, however, a major exception to the rule. Generally speaking fish won't come back if you hook them for any extended period of time. If they just knock a lure they very well may come back. Baitfish have spines in their dorsal fins, crawfish have claws. The prey ''bites back'', so it's not be highly unusual for a fish to come back to a lure. Just another example, I got on a spinnerbait bite just recently, and it seemed like literally EVERY fish hit the blades on the bait during the initial strike. I'd sweep set and have nothing, even though the bites were definite. I'd simply pump the rod and let the bait helicopter down, which drew a strike almost every time. Two distinct strikes on the same retrieve, one after the fish had already tried to eat spinning metal blades.