Okay, a little prelude to the question I am going to ask. The wife and kid were busy after work yesterday so I decided I was going to go fish a small body of water that I have driven by a million times but never tried. Basically this piece of water is an ending point for a very large creek channelthat branches off the White River in Indiana. In the picture below you can see the length of the channel.
I've seen people down there fishing before but never really gave it much thought but yesterday I had the free time so I went to check it out and HOLY COW was I surprised at what I found. There were fish EVERYWHERE! Bluegill and bass and some small gar all floating around right at the surface just hanging out. Underneath the bridge there were schools of fish (not sure what kind but something kept spooking them) so there seemed to be plenty of food for any bass to eat. Along the banks were concrete slabs plus fallen trees that had tons of fish around them. Here is a up close picture of the area. The box in red is the area I could get a lure too.
So herein lies my problem.... For all of these fish (I probably counted 40 bass in that small area and more bluegill then you could shake a stick at) I only caught 2! One on a chatterbait and another on a spinnerbait and both from under the bridge. I tried weightless senkos, brushhogs and powerworms, jigs, floating and suspending rapala's, buzzbaits, crankbaits, and a spro frog and although they would swim to the bait they just wouldn't bite.
I know when you can see fish they are hard to catch but what I experienced yesterday honestly kept me awake last night wondering what it would take to get them to bite. I was there from 5:00pm to 7:00pm so I know the heat had them lazy but surely something I threw would have enticed them.
So does anyone have any advice on what I should look into? I'm also going to get a small boat with trolling motor and see work the bank cover more as I suspect the big boys were hiding.
Thanks for any advice forthcoming!! 8-)