Read this thread last Sunday afternoon and thought, "Hmm, this has never happened to me."
Monday morning, fishing for smallies at a local pond and there's another guy there drowning nightcrawlers. Nice guy, we chatted and fished, and while he was telling me there was nothing biting, I could tell I was playing something that was likely sitting on a bed just out of sight. After a couple losses, I finally catch it. He comes over as I'm taking the hook out and admiring this beautiful 2lb. class smallie and says, "Can I have it?". All he had to put it in was a net, not even a bucket. I was like "Really???". I said there was no way in hell that I was going to take a spawning smallmouth out of that pond, and I put it back. He took my spot when I was leaving and said he'd keep it if he caught it. Fine, not my control, I guess...