I think it's an "angler" thing. Sure, the southern states have a much longer growing season but that doesn't stop a northern lake from handing you one of the best days of your lives.
It's what you take from the experience, as opposed to WHERE you experienced it, that means the most to me. Great experiences can happen anywhere you toss a line.
Well said, LBH. I have to agree. I've fished a number of states but not enough to rate one above another. Obviously, if you're after the biggest porkers you'll want to fish California, Florida, Texas, etc. I enjoy fishing just about anywhere. Once you know a lake well, your success at that lake increases. It's difficult to compare the fishing at a lake that I really don't know well from another state, to the lakes that I love and hold so dear that are near me.
Quote from RW:
I agree. Any lake that you enjoy fishing has a special quality that diffentiates it from all the others. This is what makes it great in its own way.