I agree with this statement totally. Everything you said is true. But suppose the best reel you can afford IS the most expensive reel? It may mean a few sacrifices, but like Ronnie, my fishing gear is my greatest pleasure. I'll have to listen to my wife complain anyway so I may as well catch hell for buying that new steez I'm lusting after than for not power washing the lanai. Or whatever the "honey do" de jour may be.
Avid, do you mean "What if the best reel for the money is the most expensive reel?" instead of "suppose the best reel you can afford IS the most expensive reel?" I can afford the most expensive reels, but, so far, I haven't found one that I think is the best for the money spent. However, I would agree that if I thought the most expensive reel was the best for the money spent, I would buy it. Maybe if I used one of these high end reels I would change my mind, but, currently, I can't imagine gaining enough extra benefit from these reels that would make them worth it to me to switch from my Citicas, Curados, and Stradics. It's like my car. I can afford a Lexus, etc., but why spend the money on it when a Toyota lasts just as long, and I can pour the extra money into my retirement funds? Everyone has different priorities. It's neither right nor wrong.
If any of you guys want to send me a Stella to try out for a few weeks or months to possibly change my mind, I would be open-minded enough to try it out.