First thing I ask myself is- water clarity, water temperature and what type of structure. Like most of you my plastics assortment looks like an aisle at your local tackle shop. But my go to plastics are:
Brush Hog= watermelon blake flake, watermelon red flake
Trick worm= watermelon blake flake, green pumpkin
Robo worm= Arrons magic, pro gold
But you have to find what works for you and where you are.