My take on this!
"The guide fishing is the main point of contention I have heard about over the years. My position is I'm paying you to take me fishing. You fish on your own time with your own dime."
Whether the guide fishes or needs to fish varies from lake to lake and situation to situation.
"Any variation from that is at my invitation." It's important to talk with the guide as has been noted so many times in previous posts.
As an example: The above statement put to me would get the following response. Find another guide. A client comes on my boat for a days fishing, and to use and learn some of my expertise both in location and in fishing mechanics. If the client thinks that I am going to place my reputation into their hands they need to think again. When I do fish there are several reasons to do so. First is to ensure that we are in fact on biting fish. If we are and the client is being very successful I then put my rod down. Second, I fish at times because I am teaching a particular way of fishing and I know that showing is much better than telling. I also will fish at times to keep the client fishing.
You are on my boat and are paying for my expertise. To come on my boat and expect to outline how I should do my job, to me is absurd. As I have said previously, you paid for my services, not my boat nor me. You ask my permission to come aboard, you sit where I tell you, you fish where I say, and you use the baits that I recommend. The last one, (recommended baits), is not mandatory, but then if you have a bad day then don't look at me. I have only had a few people over the years that come on board thinking that they know more than me, but then I ask them why they bothered hiring me. Most often we come to a meeting of the minds and go on to have some pretty super days on the water. If we don't then we simply head to the ramp and part company.
If you are just looking to get on the water then hire a boat. If you looking for a better than average day on the water, hire a guide and realize that it's a pretty good bet that he/she knows a heck of a lot more than you do, and that whatever methods the guide uses are probably much better than ones you might use.
If you wish to charter the boat than during your inquiry be sure to say so up front. The guy that owns the boat than will have an opportunity to say, yea what the heck, or to simply say he doesn't charter his boat. As I said, I don't just give boat rides.
There are good guides and bad guides. There are good clients and bad clients.
Just let me say: fishing and hunting are not comparable when it comes to guides.