Oh man, when I was a kid, my silver Shad Rap was IT! Everywhere I went, I'd toss that one on and catch -- local CT lakes, and when visiting family in VA and Ohio too... My friends would be begging me for a shot with it!
These days, I fish less, but have been having a lot of luck on shakey-head jigs and lipless cranks... Lures I caught nothing with as a kid... Those are definitely my go-to lures these days, with wacky senkos, DS, and a couple of cranks rounding out the "usual suspects"...