It's hard to convince a bass fisherman that anything tops a good bass. Down here in South Florida many don't even understand why someone would even want to fish for bass. My friends say to me "going panfishing, bring em along for bait", lol. I fish both fresh and salt, more emphasis on the salt. What's more fun, that's up to the individual.
I'm quite familiar with many of the salt species, I can tell you first hand it isn't like what you see on TV or read on the net. You read about the successes, not the failures that happen more often. Not near as many tarpon are landed as one may think, losing them on the first few jumps is totally commonplace. I don't fish for big ones anymore, I like catching them up to 50#, easy...........think again, tarpon are nothing short of awesome.
Cuda are really one of the most interesting fish, 1 species I do a lot of specific targeting. Getting cut off is not out of the ordinary, one of the few fish I would recommend using wire, although I don't when using traditional lures. I do make my cuda tubes with wire, far and away the most productive lures for them. It's the ones you don't see that strike, generally the followers just veer off.
I've had dolphin on the line that have taken a good 10-15 minutes to land, I use a heavy inshore 25# class rod and 6000 reel for them, I don't take anything lighter when I'm headed offshore, inshore is different. A 10# bonita on light line and light gear, I'd bet on the fish every time. In the long run I'm going to bank, as I say we read about successes and not failures.