As fish get conditioned to it, the Alabama Rig will become just another tool in a skilled angler's tool bag. I say keep the Alabama Rig as a legal tool and let the chips fall where they may. I think a lot of the griping comes from anglers with a vested interest in selling tackle (i.e. Sponsored Anglers). You can't sell 25 iterations of the A-rig like you can with crankbaits, plastics, Jerkbaits or so on.