I once wondered the same thing, so years ago, I did a simple on-the-water test to see what would happen. Here’s the write-up I did at the time:
“I pulled up to the boat ramp Friday afternoon to find a tourney about to head out. I hung around and waited for them to blast off so I wouldn’t get in their way before proceeding out. It also kind of changed my plans for the night, so at the last minute I decided to do another of those fun but meaningless on-the-water tests to see just what you can and can’t get away with when fishing for bass. In this case, power vs. finesse on the same stretch of water.
I started on a stretch of bank that encompassed 2 small coves and 2 stretches of main lake shoreline. Total distance according to Google Maps was a little over half of a mile, about 3,100 ft., and this lake is lined with docks and scattered shallow weeds. I began with power, picking up a buzzbait and running the entire stretch of bank. My thought was hit the fish first with the fast presentation while they might be active versus making that the comeback lure after already beating on them once. And I didn’t just kick the troll motor on high and wing it either, as I throw a pretty wicked buzzbait. I just steadily worked the entire shoreline area til the end. When I was done with that stretch, I had caught 11 bass and missed 3 other strikes, 1 of which I’m pretty certain was counted in the catch when I threw immediately back to the same area after missing a strike and promptly got another blowup right in the same exact spot, only this time connecting.
Next, I picked up the finesse rod with the small soft plastic and immediately turned around and reworked the exact stretch of bank I had just been through with the buzzer. It actually got a little too dark before I completed the entire stretch, but I was able to rework about 80% of it. The result...12 more bass, including the two largest of the trip. That made for a total of 23 bass landed in about 1 hour and 45 minutes.
So take what you want from this little experiment. One thing that seems obvious would be that if you move through an area throwing one type of bait, odds are good that you didn’t catch everything, only whatever was prone to hit that particular bait. This becomes a good argument for having two guys in the same boat throwing two completely different baits until they get a pattern dialed in during team tourneys, or for co-anglers to make certain they aren’t trying to work the same stretch of water as the boater up front using the same lure. Use something totally different in most cases to better your odds of catching fish behind him.“
Bottom line, sometimes it works and sometimes it doesn’t. If you feel confident or comfortable in a stretch of bank and think there might be (more) bass holding in the area, then definitely rework it with another presentation. It won’t always pan out, but it will sometimes.