I think the keys are often depth and focus. Sometimes
the fish are concentrated shallow, deep or at a specific
depth. The "focus", to keep this concept simple, is
baitfish or bugs; swimming or crawling!
As a specific example: At the Guntersville Roadtrip
lipless cranks and spinnerbaits were hot, worms were
not. On the trip last year at Pickwick both swimming
baits and soft plastics worked, but soft plastics dominated.
My suggestion is to start out with something rigged
for every depth, top to bottom. One presentation will
tend to dominate on any given day.
8-)
Roadwarrior, Your explanation is alot better then my sarcastic truth one. Thats really how I do it. But I also follow what you said. I start with my strongest most confident lure then build upon that. My goal is to break the ice and get the skunk out of the boat before I start experimenting with other lures an locations different then the seasonal patterns. Certain times of year the jig will not work as well as the trap, jerkbait, etc. But most times it will work for me.
Its also odd how it changes day to day. Even with identical weather patterns.