Good thread.
I have never been a "red" guy. Like tbone, I've been a natural colors guy in spring mostly. And I've always used chartreuse as my "light bulb" color. And I catch fish. In fact, in spring, everything seems to catch... something. But, I've been listening to guys like txchaser, and others, who seem to do better on red. I am curious how chartreuse stacks up against red.
The vision thing I was talking about has to do with a change in visual pigments in fish coming out of winter. Nothing has been done on bass that I'm aware of on this. But trout and salmon were found to shift their visual pigments to better cover longer wavelengths (reds) as they come shallow in spring. Bass also migrate from deep to shallow in spring, although to a lesser extent. So... it's not only possible, but... mebbe... even likely that bass shift their vision capabilities toward the reds as they move into the shallows.
Why is red hot so early? And then seems to peter out as spring progresses? Here’s my guess: Color vision is all about the ability to contrast objects against background lighting. Bass eyes peak in the red and green bc green maximizes light in green (vegetated) environments. And red is the contrast color, and one that “shines” in shallow water. Deeper waters tend to shift toward blues btw, which is the peak absorption for trout and salmon, and other deep water, and open water species. I’m wondering if red is so hot bc bass are coming out of “bluer” environments, and those red pigments are… novel, for lack of a better word. They then may become incorporated into shallow water vision after bass have been shallow for a while, diminishing its effect? Pure… reaching for straws here.
The other good option -and one that must be reckoned with- is that the “red phenomenon” is a myth passed on over the years. I believe it started in Texas actually, and has since spread… all the way into MY tackle box in recent years. :)) Question is, do I want to spend the time to experiment with “red” this spring? Time rolls by fast this time of year. I do not want to be chasing a… myth. But, I hear experiences like txchasers loud and clear. Glad he’s out doing that and reporting it. I may just join you one year. This year? Hmmmm… I don’t even own any red jerkbaits. I did add some red lipless to the arsenal, and even, just this winter, painted an old chrome Rattl-Trap red with a dark back. It’s in the early spring box, ready to roll.