i have bed fished for a few years now. to me, there no bigger adrenaline rush than matching wits with a giant bass, knowing it will probably be the biggest one you will have a shot at all year. there's just something about trying to fool a fish you can see that transcends the excitement of any other type of fishing to me, even topwater. to me, it's fishing in its purest form. unless you've ever set up on a giant female bass, it's impossible to describe the feeling. those who have know exactly what i'm talking about. there are a special set of skills involved, and it is admittedly still a work in progress for me. but i would bed fish 12 months a year if it were possible. it's just that addictive to me.
with that said though, i cannot place enough emphasis on getting your pix and getting the fish back in the water. big fish are just so special. and it is nice to know those genetics will be passed on for the future generations. taking the female off the bed for a quick photo session is usually a lot less harmful to the nest/egss than it would be to catch the male since he usually has the bulk of guard duty.
i don't tournament fish, but speaking from experience with bed fishing, i'm not sure how good a strategy it would be to bank on bed fishing to win a tournament unless you are very, very good at it. it's already been mentioned how tough it can be at times. it's probably a good strategy for a kicker, but maybe not the best strategy in the world for putting 5 fish in the livewell.
as for the unfairness of it, bass fishing itself is unfair. we are always "taking advantage" of one or another of the bass' instincts, or at least that's what we are trying to do. to those who question the "fairness" of bed fishing, my response is pretty much always the same. throw away all your 10 bearing reels, super sensitive graphite rods, superlines, chemically sharpened hooks, scent attractants, electronics, 60 mph bass boat, super quiet trolling motor, polarized glasses, ultra realistic baits, etc. fish with with a cane pole from the bank or a jon boat that you paddle yourself. if you are willing to do that, i'll listen to your gripes about fairness. if not, it all just sounds a bit hypocritical and ridiculous to me.
i don't know of anyone who is criticized for NOT bed fishing. i just wish that those of us who do it got the same courtesy sometimes. just my opinions here though. this is a very interesting topic and it would be nice to have a civil discussion without this thread getting shut down. we'll see.................... ;D