Back to simple:
The "right" bait in the wrong place never works,
but the "wrong" bait in the right place sometimes does!
"Location and presentation", it really can be that simple.
8-)
I think it is really that simple, however, determining the "right" bait and the "right location" for any given day, water temp, season, weather conditions is what constantly drives me mad. I occasionally get it right and get on fish, only to go back the next week under similar conditions, or so it appears, and get skunked.
Paul, it appears to me that this is the perfect research location for your writing endeavor. I would pay a lot of money for something that passes the scrutiny of this group.
Being a relative newbie to this sport and an information junkie, I am constantly searching for the why as much as the how. Maybe I have a chemical imbalance, but the fact that something worked is not as important and why it worked. Recently I have been searching for information on fisheries biology and ecology and what I have found is scattered at best and nearly unreadable even with my college and engineering background. A one stop source of coherent and accurate information on the where fish live and why they bite would certainly be a valuable tool for someone like me. Yes I know that this site is full of wonderfully informational threads, but, finding them is not so easy.
I have spent over 150 days on the water in the last year and have kept a log. I can tell you what did and did not work (mostly the later), weather conditions, temp, water levels and where I was. I could tell you what might work next week on a given lake, but I can not, with any certainty, tell you why. The lack of "'why" is the reason it is not always repeatable.
I know that "somedays they just aint bitin" and maybe I'm not entirely stable, but those are my thoughts on the subject.
Keep them coming guys
FD