No, I'm not suggesting that one is better than the other, just that color it seldom makes a difference, but if one lure is working better for you where you fish then by all means run with that, I doubt the color is the reason though, and if fishing "pretty" lures is your thing, then by all means. The Iovino and Yellow Magic poppers are both great lures, but there are some subtle but consequential differences. Fish the two in the same color (with the same tail feathers) and then you will be closer to discovering why it's so. The YM fishes a tad "bigger" so I prefer it over the Splash-It when there is a ripple, but in really calm conditions I give the Iovino the nod, although lately I've been fishing the boss pop out of the package (which is rare for me) and it's as good as it gets. Did I mention I have a popper problem?...