Have a lot of super clear water up here and I use to use Picasso Jigs which have a fairly weak rattle that snaps off rather easy. I would be catching fish, then all of a sudden, not even a tap. Then I would look and see the rattle had busted off, would put on another, then I would just start catching fish. So I just always go with rattles. I have gone over to Terminator Pro Top Secret jigs, they have the band with two rattle chambers so you never have an issue putting on trailers or have a rattle chamber sliding down.