I would rather be ordering lures when it is that cold, but one lure that I have used since a kid and still do here in Florida, is the Crappie Sized Blakemore Roadrunner in 1/16,1/8,1/4, or 1/32...BPS has a cheap model called the stump jumper which comes with some cool looking soft baits on the back that only BPS sells, and I often buy just the pack of 10 heads and blades, and then add a small 1-2" soft bait.
I would imagine the Ned Rig would be my first choice now or a Slider Worm or a Gitzit Tube on a Slider Head as it glides to the bottom like a dead shad....Small Jigs like the BItsy Bug, little craws like the small Zoom Critter craw.....I have been with guys who also kill them on a suspending Jerkbait on light line 6-8lb test clear line, and will let the lure soak for long pauses...I am still learning that technique, but it seems to produce bigger fish, the Rogue & Suspending Bomber Long A are popular, as are the Megabass 110's, but I think they are only worth the money if you have a passion for Jerkbait fishing.I am not good enough to know the difference from the Knock offs, but I have been outfished by them before....
This may sound crazy, as this brand is not very popular, but a Creme Mad Dad Minnow is like the Shad Rap of lipless baits, and it comes in a small version that casts easily, falls slowly, and it is soft so it can go through cover or any weed growth left, and only cost $2 each. Its a good bait, but I would also try waking them up if you have a hard bottom and they are hugging it in a neutral move with a Spro Aruku shad hopped on the bottom like a jig...I have had it work after cold fronts in places I am familar with where I know hold fish, you just need to be ready to lose a few....