In the last 10 years or so since I have started to get serious about deep cranking, the overwhelming theme for me is.......................something with a little (sometimes a lot) of chartruse in it it out fish's any other deep crank color I have had by a wide margin. I have also found that the colors I like for shallow, mid depth, and lipless cranks, are next to useless in deep cranks, and vice-versa. About the only color that works for me in ALL cranking situations isChart. Sexy Shad, .............then again, I tend to only have success on that color shallow cranking in dirty water, but deep cranking it works fine in dirty AND clear water...go figure. My best producing shallow cranks are bluegill/perch/sunfish and red/orange craw colored baits, yet deep cranking they haul water (most of the time). So through a long trial and error process, I now only carry and use (I own every color of the rainbow...I'm just as much of a tackle junkie as the next guy LOL) for deep cranking these colors for these situations......(all SK 3xd's, 5xd's and 6xd's BTW):
Chart. Sexy Shad: #1 go to color anytime, any where, if they are not biting this, they are likely NOT on a deep crank bite.
Chart. Blue/Back: This is my change up bait when they ARE biting on #1, before I declare the bite is over, I like to run this around for a bit in the areas I was getting bit on #1...
Chart. Belly Craw: When I am tossing a deep crank into the weeds and ripping it out, this bait seems to shine over the other two for some reasons I don't know, but I can't argue with what the results,so I roll with it.
Sexy Ghost Minnow: Ultra clear water stuff when you have to "burn" a deep diving crank. It is translucent, so they don't get that great look at it or big splash of color in their face, but has just "enough" chart. in it to keep the theme of "chart = deep cranking success" theme going.
And the one odd ball to my whole chart. based deal....Rootbeer.............smallmouth love this freaking color.
NOW..............after that long winded post....I'll add this....these are the deep cranking lessons I have learned on my home waters, and apply to the late spring- late fall period. For some reason, early spring, or in the fall after the water has gone into the low 50's..........the chart. based stuff tapers off, and that's when the red or orange craw colored deep cranks (despite what I said previously) have a little window of jumping ahead of the ones listed above.