While Indiana hasn't seen 11 inches of rain this year, we do have enough rain/runoff to severely muddy up some of my favorite ponds/lakes. This is when I do my own personal checklist to figure out what to throw
Bass seem to use one/combination/all of three of their abilities to hunt food. Sight (their advanced underwater eyesight), Smell (or taste or whatever), Vibration (like "hearing" with their lateral line)
When I get to a body of water I assess the water to determine the most probable form of navigation and food detection they'll use, then tailor my lure to appeal to the likely most dominant form of detection. In super gin-clear water, they're likely to use sight as a considerably larger portion of their detection methods, so I'll pay close attention to "match the hatch". In extremely muddy water, they're likely only able to rely on their lateral line as their primary detection method, maybe eyesight as a secondary form.
So in your case, and mine some of the time this year, muddy water would call for something that makes a helicopter engine feel like a small tap. Use something that straight up massages your arm as you're reeling it in. I use a black/blue chatterbait with a RageTail trailer, the blade of the chatterbait is curved downward at the top for extra thump. Man, that thing will nearly rattle the fillings in your teeth. But it's worked wonders this year with muddy water for me. I don't use a scent and I use mainly a dark color in case they're using sight to fine-tune their approach as they get closer to my chatterbait. Reel it in at a speed just fast enough to get the blade thumping, that way the bass have more time to hit the slowly moving target.
I'm sure a large profile dark colorado-blade spinnerbait, maybe even a loud lipless crank would also get it done. I just know nothing in my tackle box thumps like that chatterbait.