Here's the thing- Red Craw is a KNOWN good color throughout the South during the pre-spawn. It's no surprise to me that it was that color, none at all. Look in any of their boxes and I'll guarantee you there was a LOT of that same color or a variation thereof. It would have been full of Red Craw, Demon, Chili Craw, Chili Bowl...
It happens every year, in and out. When KVD won on the Black Chart 1.5, it sold out in hours all across the US. Then, a year later, they introduced the Catouache Special color, and said, this is what he REALLY was fishing- IT sold out all across the US. When Chris Lane won it on Otters- you couldn't buy them regardless of color. Cliff Pace? Couldn't find a V+M football or twin tail anywhere they were sold. Think anglers aren't looking for a magic bullet? Look at the threads here, even! "Top Five Baits" "If you could only have Ten Lures", "Top Three Soft Plastics", "Soft PLastic Colors". It never ends. We, as a whole, are always looking for the latest and greatest. That's the way it is.