I’ll take a stab at this. A little background first. I consider myself primarily/ first and foremost a plastics fisherman. I mainly fish deep, clear water reservoirs in Southern California with maximum depths of 200 feet plus (see Diamond Valley Lake). I primarily use 6 and 8 pound test due to the gin clear water and 20 plus feet of visibility. 10 pound test is “heavy” out here for everyday worm fishing. Lol. It kills me when good ol’boys back east talk about deep water crankin’ or offshore structure fishing in 15’ of water and having to drop down to 10 pound test. Deep water structure fishing for me starts at 40 plus feet! Lol.
As far as brand goes, I exclusively fish my own brand plastics now, but more on that later in another thread. Colors are usually matched to the lake/ water clarity and conditions. I prefer “natural” colors i.e. Green Pumpkin, Watermelon, Pumpkin, etc although we all know location and presentation are by far more important. Techniques overlap with the different plastics and colors. I exclusively use Gamakatsu hooks as I feel they provide the best quality at price point and offer a hook suited for every technique I employ which are primarily Drop Shot, T-Rig, and C-Rig. High speed reels are the norm and technique specific rods are standard issued with set ups dedicated to only a single technique.
Below I will list a generalized list of baits that I swear by. Like I said I exclusively use Rude Baits® now but for years used and drew inspiration from Zoom®, GYBC® and RoboWorm. In no particular order of importance as presentations vary from day to day, hour to hour, and spot to spot here is a generalized list of my top producers;
4.5” and 6” Finesse Worm – I primarily use these type of worms for Drop Shot and Nail Weight presentations. Drop Shot generally in 10 to 50 foot plus. Nail Weight for 10 foot or less. I use my own version of finesse worm with a size 2 Gamakatsu Drop Shot/ Split Shot hook with ¼ or 3/8 oz. ball style Drop Shot weight. Out this way very light, subtle and translucent versions of Purple, Pink, and Blue work very well.
5” Stik Bait – Weightless and weed less. Always! Texeposed weightless weed less presentations for generally 20 foot or less. Although as painful as it may be sometimes, this technique can kill it in 20 plus foot of water if you can stand it! Usually a Gammy 3/O EWG gets the call. With best producing colors being darker naturals, Green Pumpkin, June Bug, Grape, etc.
5.5” Creature Bait – I use these for primarily picking apart pieces of visible or metered cover although they are great for covering structure as well. T-Rigged for cover and C-Rigged for structure. Gammy 3/O Round Bend with a 3/8 – ½ oz. Bullet weight for the T-Rig and ½ - ¾ oz for the C-Rig. Junebug has always been a top producer for me.
6” Straight Tail Worm – Used primarily with a T-Rig for picking apart isolated pieces of cover. Although the Drop Shot is a So Cal go-to, this may be the most versatile of the whole bunch. Works from one foot of water to 40 foot plus. Gammy 2/O O’Shaughnessy or 2/O Round Bend with 3/8 – ½ oz. Bullet weight. Any of the aforementioned colors will work as long as you find the fish.
6” Lizard – This is both my go-to C-Rig and sight fishing bait. 3/O or 4/O Gammy EWG with either a 3/8 oz. weight for a sight fishing T-Rig or ½ - ¾ oz. egg weight for C-R-rig. I have had the best luck with Pumpkin and Junebug for the C-Rig and Chartreuse for sight fishing.
3’ and 4” Swim Bait – When I say Swim Bait I mean “Swim Tail” style threaded on to a triangular style lead head. The same style you see on all of those A-Rigs. ¼, 3/8, and 1/2 oz. get the call. I primarily use them to scrape the bottom working uphill on long, tapering, main lake points from 50 foot of water back up to 10 foot. A great search bait. Also good for breaking fish in wolf pack when burned back to the boat. Shad (Smoke) pattern is my favorite. Probably the bait of the listed above I use the least in fresh water but is an absolute go-to killer in salt water. It is the standard bait in which all Calico, Sand, and Spotted Bay Bass fisherman use the most.
Honorable Mention – Soft Jerk baits, Grubs, Curl Tails, Tubes, and Large Worms have all produced for me throughout the years but the six listed above are my go-to bait day in day out.
I hope the post above was informative as you can see I take pride in fishing my plastics. Whether it’s soaking a Drop Shot in 40 foot of water off a main lake point or Flippin’ and Pitchin’ tules pockets in the back of a cove I love fishing plastics.