The paddletail baits (Bastrix and their knockoffs) are kind of like a compromise. They tend to catch bigger fish then most guys are used to catching so guys are satisfied with them. They also occasionaly catch a trophy fish as all baits occasionaly do. Also "real" swimbaits do catch small fish wich gives fuel to the argument that paddletails work just as good. However if you could take he average size of bass caught on real trophy producing swimbaits and compare it to the average fish caught on paddletails or any other bait, the real swimbait would by far have the highest average. It is not uncommon to catch an 8-10lber on a real swimbait. I would classify paddletail type baits as kicker fish baits. "Real" swimbaits are harder to define then they used to be. It doesnt take a huge bait to make it a proven trophy catcher. It takes cacthing trophies with it. With all the "swimbaits" out there there are only a few that are proven producers of trophy bass. The Hudd is probably the all time trophy producing swimbait and I have no doubt that since it came to market, in that same time, it hase produced more trophy bass then any other bait including jigs and woms etc. I also think That my gills (soft and hard) are high up on the list of trophy producing baits. There are several others to, that just seem to have the IT factor. Big bass like to eat small fish. That is always there main forrage if given the choice. Many guys will say you dont need "real swimbaits" to cacth big bass. That the paddletails work just fine because they catch plenty of big fish with them. The difference is guys Like Butch and Mike and Fish Chris arent fishing for 10 lbers in lakes that have 20lbers. They are targeting the biggest fish in thier lakes. They are using the baits they feel give them the best odds at catching that upper 1%. There are guys doing this all over the country and world with the same "real" swimbaits. The biggest fish in thier lakes may be 10lbs and thats what they are targeting not just a bigger class. The Jappanese throw huge baits at those monster bass. When I target trophy bass I want a bait that matches what I think they want to eat. I want the right size, color, and action. I want a guy standing 20ft away from me to not be able to tell that my bait is not a real fish. If it will fool a human, it will fool a fish. I can spot a paddletail from 100+ ft. Swimbaits are not always the best choice but alot of times they are. I still fish plastics and jigs and I know Mike does to but most of the time its "real" swimbaits. Oh and BTW paddletail baits can be alot of fun. They are just a different tool that produce different results.