Mcnabb

[NewAngler]

It doesn't take a genius to figure out that most of Campbell's failings weren't his fault. He has had as many coaches, systems, OC's as he has years in his college AND pro career. He is a good quarter back with absolutley NO confidence, and NO line. You give him him the o-line that Favre had this year, I bet he would double his stats.

Oh, did you guys forget to look at his stats, or are you judging him from the win/loss category? Probably the latter.

Campbell has been treated like CRAP the past 2 years or so, and deserves to be in a city that will appreciate him. It's hard to say that a city even will, because of people like you guys jumping all over a guy for a lack of support on his line, and a front office that has NO clue on what they're doing.

On to McNabb...

I'm not quite sure how I feel about this yet. Like another guy has said, I've HATED this man ever since wearing an Orange jersey. Is he a better quarterback than Campbell? Last years numbers don't show much difference, except in one category; deep balls. Eight deep balls completed for 40+ yards, and 17 for McNabb. Campbell never had the plays called for him though. McNabb also had Desean Jackson who caught 11 (?) of those.McNabb will have a different play caller this year than Campbell, and will not have a fast receiver like Jackson.

Motivational leader? McNabb wins this category. Something that has been lacking in this town on the football field for quite sometime. I'm excited to see him get fired up and march his troops onto the field, hype them up in the huddle, and get fire under theirAss finally.

Solution to a 4-12 team? Not if they think this is going to be the band-aid to heal their wounds. They still have no line, they have a huge salary eater (Haynesworth), that doesnt give it half the effort he needs to, and have 3 running backs at the age of 30. OH, and I am hearing reports that the Skins haven't ruled out drafting a quarterback at pick number 4, and said that if Bradford is available, the will, "have a hard time picking someone else." Ridiculous.

[shootermcbob]

the redskins have given Campbell permission to seek a trade. I don't think he has played his best football yet, but you have to wonder if Mike Shanahan has ZERO interest in him????

As for McNabb, I think he has been under-appreciated his entire career. As Matt stated earlier, he has never had a pro bowl reciever to throw to... that lasted longer than 18 months. And the eagles went to the super bowl when TO was there. They are finally getting some weapons on offense, Jackson, Maclin, McCoy, Celek, that is a lot of firepower. And Now McNabb won't be there to enjoy it.

As a cowboys fan, it would not bother me if the trade didn't work out for either team. But that still leaves those darn Giants...who beat us twice last year.  >