Creature baits are one of my top 3 baits overall for bass fishing. Like a couple people said the full-size Brush Hogs just don't work for me. Tiny, baby, super, and even the new mid-size all work well. Below I will list my top 5 Creature baits in no particular order.
1. RI Smallie Beaver=GP, California 420, (actually let me know if you find a color that doesn't work)
2. Zoom Baby Brush Hog= GP, Scuppernong, Avacado
3. Zoom Super Hog= GP, Scuppernong
4. Yamamoto Kreature Bait= GP, Orange with green and black flake.
5. Berkeley Power Hog 4"= GP, Solid Black, Castaic choice
6. Honorable mention goes to Berkeley Mud Critter= GP, Solid black, Pumkinseed.
Now I know everyone has favorite baits of their own. The list about is based on 20 years of fishing and not a single good day with a bait. If you notice there are only a few colors that have stood the test of time.
Allen