I have been lucky to be able to have fished a lot of different reels this past two years and as cabin fever has started to set in, despite it being almost 60 degrees today, I wanted to start writing a few reviews. So I decided for whatever reason to start with Lew's.
First off I wanted to add a little disclaimer...... I am not a big fan of Lew's reels in general prior to getting my hands on a few. So I know that sounds biased but I did approach this with sort of an opened mind.
First reel I tried was a the Hyper Mag. One of the guys I work on reels for bought it at the beginning of the year and asked if I would clean the excess oil and grease (which there was a lot of oil but no grease) off of it and spool it up with some 12lb Stren. He said he was not in a hurry to get it back since he was headed into surgery and I could fish at my leisure until he recovered. So prior to working on it, I fished it for a few hours just to see what it felt like. And it was just OK. I like how it was light weight and felt awesome in hand. It was sort of smooth but just different. I hated the handles though but they were good in the rain. I really wanted to like this reel but it just didn't do it for me compared to other reels well below it's price point. What I expected this reel to be was a light weight finesse powerhouse but it wasn't. I struggled to get good casting distance with this reel on a weightless senko but it did well with heavier jigs and baits. The thing that disturbed me the most was the breaking. I found I was constantly adjusting it to stop it from backlashing. It would be fine one minute and backlash the next. If I am messing with the breaks, I am missing out on fishing. After cleaning, lubing and fishing for about 10 more hours, things improved some but not much. Overall, this is a good reel if you like Lew's reels. I liked the feel of it, it was easy to work on, the cast control knob with the line weight is a nice touch and the hook keeper is genius but it just was not my taste. It was just too different from what I have fished in the past. I gave it back to the owner and wished him the best.
Second was the Mach 2, the greenish one that comes with the combo. I bought this at DSG for $50 on clearance. I thought since I liked the way the Hyper Mag felt in hand, I would try one. It felt pretty much the same as the above reel but worse and heavier. I returned it after one use.
Last, and strangely my favorite, is the Carbon Fire. I bought this at DSG as well for $12 ($45 clearance + 75% off) back in May. I have to say I was blown away at how good this reel is. Not because of what I paid for it but because it just worked well and felt good in hand. It's surprisingly smooth and it cast as well if not better than the two above. The breaking system (magnetic) works well (very similar to Quantum reels). I think it would make for a great beginner reel. On a side note, I would put it pretty close to the Shimano SLX.
I guess I can see why people like Lew's reels but to me all the ones I fished still feel a lot like BPS and Pflueger's offerings (which isn't necessarily a bad thing). They just don't break away from that feel of a mass produced product where all the reels in the line up feel the same. It, to me, boils down to personal preference. I think I will continue to enjoy the Carbon Fiber for years to come though.