I think there is a couple of things going on. As Mark said, I, too, think you may have just a few winds too many on the spool. I always close the bail by hand anyway, every cast, and that can help too. And it does take a couple of days out for it to loosen up a little. But the biggest thing is that you were throwing a weightless worm...it's the weight, or your hand in a rag, to put tension on the line as it comes in so naturally it's going to lay a little loose. Try it on the water; you'll love it.