lol - no, I wasn't trolling - I had just never thought about how swappers handle fly gear.
So, if I followed you correctly, you cast and reel right handed on spinning and casting gear; fly fishing you also have a right hand crank reel (or flipped to reel on the right depending on reel), but strip with your left hand? Unless you hook up with a fish that you want to put on reel, then mid fight you swapped hands, for those you did put on the reel? Excluding your immediate swap practice last night, lol. I think this may be one scenario where I think there is a clear advantage to not swapping hands, lol. I guess I'm kind of lucky in that regard, as I am a right hand rod, left hand cranker regardless of the style...
And I think the nascar / pro angler vs commute / weekend warrior was this:
Pro's are more capable, finely tuned professionals who are capable of swapping hands with less risk / impact than an average Joe. While there may (or may not) be an advantage/disadvantage, their total skill set and experience put's them so far ahead of weekend warriors that they can effectively nullify any negatives with their extreme proficiency. Those same disadvantages (if they exist) would more significantly impact WW because they are not skilled at the same level.
While I am not really convinced one way or the other on actual impact, that concept I 100% agree with, and is relatively inarguable. To debate that would be akin to debating that most WW's bait casting skills are equal to the pros. Sorry, but very very few are as competent. I think there is room to debate the technical risk of a swap vs the gains of comfort and more natural approach for those not as highly skilled. In that regard, I think the amateurs biggest benefit would come from what is natural and feels comfortable - regardless of the risk gained during a swap.
Randomly, I also just thought about the scenario where a fish does instantly strike as soon as the lure hits the water ... I guess it could even be argued, that since one of the biggest issue's rookies have when topwater fishing is setting the hook too soon, perhaps that delay during the swap could actually be a benefit by slowing down the hook set reaction time. Or, it could fluster the angler and they try setting mid swap, without cranking out slack, and miss more. IDK, lol.
Like I said way back, this debate will go on as long as fishing does. I don't think there is a "right" or "wrong" way - just go with what works for you. Maybe you miss more fish, maybe you don't. As long as you are having fun and sharing that fun with others, who cares!