Fishman -- Let me start with this...
2017 Lake Okeechobee
Rick Clunn
Day 1, total keepers. 2
2! Rick Clunn! Member of the Bass Fishing Hall of Fame. Won 4 of the 32 Classics hes fished in, Clunn. 2 fish. 3lb, 14 oz total!
Remember that next time you get down on yourself.
I have not been fishing as much over the last few years as I used to, and I can tell a difference. I'm not nearly as tuned in, and the instincts of what to throw when doesn't have the confidence it used to have. So I fell ya and that "lost" feeling at times. I almost feel like I've started lake fishing all over again, and the first couple years it was a big learning experience. I think if we stick with some basics to get on track we will be fine though.
KISS -- Cat nailed that! Keep your colors simple. Don't fret over bone vs white vs this other color of white with a fleck of what ever. Think light / dark / natural / bright to start. When in doubt, fail to natural colors. Think strike zone, not lure first. What I mean by that is, don't think --- oh it's a cloudy day - I should throw a (insert whatever lure)... think about how the time of year, and weather should position the fish. Then think about all of the types of lures you have that would be productive in that scenario. You can throw the perfect lure, to the most perfect structure on the lake, with exactly the color the fish want --- but if they aint there, you aint catchin' em'. If you think out where they SHOULD be, then you can pick a more appropriate lure to match that instead of trying to fit them to the lure. That's his top three picks for this time of year, based on where the fish "should" be and how they "should" be acting.
ie, if its late winter, water team is 43 degrees - chances are you are not going to pick up a lot of top water bites no mater how bad you want to throw TW. Same lake, water temps in the mid 70's, late spring / early summer, late evening after a short brisk rain --- well, now you may be onto something! The point being, think about where they most likely will be, then fit your selection to that to start. And it sounds like you are doing just that, the problem is when they are doing what they should be.
Now when things go sideways I do a few things. Requalify, downsize, simplify. Requalify -- I rethink where I am and why. Am I in the right type of spot? Should they really be here, or am I just fishing here because I've caught fish here before. I love the back of this cove, it's where I caught that monster two years ago, I know they where here that fall! But, it's mid-summer. Water temps are in the 80's, and its a blue bird sky. I've done that. EXACTLY that... and felt like an idiot for spending time there wondering why I'm not getting bit.
If you are in the "right" kind of spot, downsize and simplify. You are having trouble picking up a bite, you can't fine tune a pattern until you find it first. Match your color to the conditions, and a lure to the depth you want to target. Just go smaller. Find "a" bite -- then start working up from there. Some smaller fish will be more willing to bite than the big guys, sure --- but, if you haven't been bit at all, you need "something" to go on. It may feel like its a spinner bait day to you, but maybe they really want something off the bottom. If you start going from nothing on a white spinnerbait, then pick up a few guys on a black 4" worm... you have an idea to work from.
As for "finesse", here's how I look at it. If the bite is on, then what's the point? If you can burn cranks, spinnerbaits, buzzbaits, etc. and get good bites - I'd stick with it. If you are getting hawgs off big jigs and 8" worms, keep getting hawgs! But, if you are not ... then, I start to think more finesse. I'll be 100% candid, when things get really wonky I drop to a 3" grub, usually white or pumpkinseed. I can fish shallow, mid, deep or bounce/drag the bottom as slowly as I want. I can target brush, rocks, flats, dropoffs, laydowns, etc. All with one lure. And I know fish will eat a grub. And you can start a pattern from there and work you way back up. If I "finesse" my way into a bite, I can figure out basic color, depth and what they are relating to. From there, I can build my way into a better bait for a bigger bite. So yeah, nothing wrong with going finesse to find the fish. IMO. Some days, that's ALL they want anyway lol.
One thing I really like doing is working with your partner, especially to pattern the bite. We almost always do the same thing... start with whatever we "think" will work. Size, color, etc. But, if we aren't on fish asap, we split things up. one deeper, one more shallow. one dark, one light. etc. If we are on a point, and he's getting bit on a spinnerbait coming across and I'm not dragging a worm or vise versa --- that tells us a lot. Next point it may be a black crank vs a white spinnerbait, etc. then it may be a bluegill crank vs a blue and black spinnerbait. The key being we don't fish the same thing unless we're confident that IS the right choice... and heck, even then we still tend to mix things up looking for a better bite lol.