I would say my all time favorite lure for bass fishing all year, and it is great over weeds, slow rolled...Bomber Long 15A, gold chart FL color and I have a few without paint, but I would not sell them for 5 new Pointers with perfect paint because they won't sound the same, or have the same action, I carry roughly 25 long a floaters, 10 suspenders, 10-15 Redfins, ripplin red fins, Rebel sbroke backs in silver black floating and suspend dots if needed for all, and of course a few Rapala F9-F13, and J11-J13 and flat raps in silver black, silver blue, silver orange...but my best long A's have some yellow and orange I added with a marker under chin, 2 lines of red near the old gills were, and depending on how rough the water is or how shallow I need it to go, I will modify diving depth and often a super fast rise is better than slow when worked mid day in summer over weeds everyone else uses a fluke. If you watch a jerkbait for thousands of hours, I truly believe I can anticipate half of the strikes that occur not counting the fish that choke it as soon as it lands as that fish would hit anything...I find Larger Bass hit the longer profile cranks and shallow wakes, and if I let it dive a few inches and I see a rise in water around the lure, usually a bass it under it and that is when you need to either kill it and wait, or snap it just right and if loaded correctly, the long a can do a 3/4 turn with a crazy roll that just looks like a nervous shiner...
Now, lures are tools that we all use based on our own experiences as I know plenty of people who don't carry any and like only Rapala, but most have some Horton Pro long a suspenders, the gold chart and gold prism long a, and nothing says shiner better than a redfin or ripplin redfin and I would put that statement against a swimbait, but its about confidence. I hate crankbaits that go deep, but I know the fat free shad would be #2 behind only the Norman DD22 but I would rather carolina rig a broke back or jointed minnow instead of cranking and that works awesome with a fast floater again and using some thicker line helps....
I do feel the older models work better and they sound completely different as the new A's sound like hooks banging together, the older lures had a distant knock not a rattle, and I like hooking fish with 3 trebles in tough areas...The flat A is the cold water killer that actually can be cast far as the shad rap is light. the fat a's are cheap but pound for pound, I would say Pradco has the best jerkbaits, ripbaits, and cranks not as much, and I like Rapala but would rather go bagleys for Balsa personally...Cast a 5" gold red red fin across a pond, and if sloooooooo waking which is really trying to dive but won't, the ripplin redfin looks like it goes backwards, that is my new weapon for this year for clear water, it looks so realistic and if walleye and smallies love it the bass here will as well....I like Lucky's and all, but I have a bait from another company that I would choose over the sammy, Pointer, Flash minnow, and its all about finding your own niche, I like the stuff I know how to work, and just trust that I will figure out if I am working too fast or slow, I hate a new bait and not knowing where it is at all times or if it is maybe tilted sideways, I like seeing it at all times, steering is important for sucess in Florida.