What is your favorite plastic? (who makes it, price, where you bought, color?)
Reaction Innovations Beaver, 5-6$, tons of vendors, Magic Craw
Under what circumstances will you throw any type of plastic?
Ice out to Ice up on a Jig, shakey head, pitched into cover, open water, deep structure, everywhere
How do you determine what color and type of plastic you will throw? Also, what determines if it gets some sort of weighting?
Water clarity and/or weather/sky conditions. Cover and how much it takes to get in and out of it. Open water I generally throw it on a shakey head or a 5/16oz tungsten weight. The smallie beaver is a bait I use on a shakey head and in open water more than in cover and it gets more bites depending on the time of year. The large ones I usually always use in grass, wood, laydowns, brush, etc.
What hook do you recommend for certain plastics?(who makes it, size)
This could go on and on forever as there are thousands of variables like rod, line, cover, etc. For example, I won't use the same hook on a 3 power rod for a smallie beaver as I will on a 5 power rod.
Pertaining to the bait described in this post, I use the following hooks:
Secret Lures Widegap shakey head
4/0 Gama heavy cover flipping hook
3/0 VMC flipping hook
3/0 EWG and bend the hook point out 1-2 degrees
Are there any plastics that you've tried that you do NOT suggest?
Havoc Jerk Shad. Awful action. Has the durability of dry sand. Don't bite the tip off to get it on a swim jig. The taste is the foul.
Are there any lure specific plastics that get a certain rod?
I have a ton of different rods for different plastics based on how and where I'm throwing them.
What techniques do you use for your selected plastic? Any tips here would be great for readers!
I answered this in the hook portion
If there is anything else you wish to add to further the "knowledge" of your favorite plastic, do so here!
Most, if not all, soft plastics will catch fish better than others at some point.